Smith & Daughters

Melbourne’s veg*n community love Smith & Daughters. They really, really, REALLY love Smith & Daughters. Even since it opened in March of this year, the overwhelming positive, rapturous, orgasmic reviews have been consistently appearing across the food blogosphere ever since. And I got so excited. Because an all vegan restaurant by the folks responsible for the vegan food at Gasometer, at the East Brunswick Club, at Sweetwater Inn, this was something to be properly keen for.

However, I was in the midst of saving for my Canada and America trip, and a quick check of the reviews revealed that Smith & Daughters was on the expensive end of the spectrum, and there was frankly no way I could have justified a proper exploration of the menu at that time. So a lot of months passed by before I managed to slip in on a quiet Saturday morning in the company of Steph to experience the weekend brunch menu.

First of all, because I want this to be the ultimate take away anyone has of Smith & Daughters, the service here is the best I have ever had in Melbourne. THE. BEST. Every person on staff we came in contact with was friendly and helpful without being obtrusive, and are clearly passionate about every aspect of the business. This is such a rare thing to feel as a customer, obvious love for a place radiating off the well-turned out staff, especially in hospo, so it is well worth noting.

The brunch menu is smaller food-wise than the standard menu, but it is a bit cheaper for those of you watching your wallets (although a few items’ price points still made my eyebrows raise in an “oh really?” fashion). The menu is heavily Spanish and Latin American influenced, meaning lots of omelettes and mock chorizo and burritos, although it did mean that due to my aversion to capsicum/peppers a lot of the savoury dishes had to be discounted, but that is the fault of my tastebuds only.

There was no capsicum in the breakfast burrito though! Instead it’s ample insides were filled with fat chunks of tofu, sauteed garlic kale and a spicy mix of black beans and mock chorizo (I couldn’t quite figure out what the chorizo was made out of, as it had been ground up, but I would imagine maybe something mushroom based?), with a mound of guacamole served on the side. There is also the option, for a few extra dollars, to have cashew cheese added to the burrito, which I chose not to have because I try not to have too much nut-based dairy analogues since I feel uncomfortable with the fact they’re not the best ecologically (don’t get me started on the deal with almond milk). This was a mistake, as even with the avocado, the burrito filling was very crumbly, and very dry. All the fixings were well flavoured, but the dry, collapsible texture definitely got to me after a while. You shouldn’t have to add on an extra (especially priced) component to make a dish come together.

Smith & Daughters clearly understand what their runaway customer favourite dish is, so even on the brunch menu you will find the mock tuna and pea croquettas. These seem to have been a feature in every review I’ve read, and people are ecstatically wild for them. You get one fat croquetta, perfectly deep-fried to a crispy orange hue, sitting in a schmear of caper aioli and with a wedge of lemon to be squeezed over the top. The inside manages to be simultaneously fluffy and moist, and you can see flecks of pea in among the mock tuna. The flavour didn’t seem overtly fishy to me, which was a bit strange since I’m ordinarily oversensitive to seafood flavours and scents. It was a perfectly fine finger of fried goodness, but I didn’t experience a scene of divine revelation. Do I also think the fact that one croquetta costs $5 is a bit of a liberty? Yes, yes I kinda do.

There is a very extensive juices menu here at brunch, which always perks me up as I love my fruits whizzed up and served with a garnish. I was peering covetously at a JUG of juice that was being sipped through a straw by someone at an adjoining table (a JUG OF JUICE! For ONE person! What a joy), but decided I should be sensible (boo) and just get a glass. Like a fool I can’t remember it’s actual name, but it was one of the more simple concoctions available, consisting of grilled apple, mint and cinnamon all juiced up and topped with a fan of fresh apple slices. This was DYNAMITE. Spicy and crisp and like having a fresh apple pie in a glass, it was both comforting and refreshing. I am very much intrigued by the sound of Smith & Daughters’ cocktail menu; if they are anything like the juices on offer then I think you could have a very delicious alcoholic evening there.

I don’t like to be even mildly contrary in the face of overwhelming praise. I’m actually quite alarmingly populist at heart when it comes to food and want to be able to join in with an experience that has attracted such cheers and love with enthusiastic gusto. I certainly don’t want to downplay what Smith & Daughters are doing in setting up what is in many ways a unique dining option for the veg*n community (and by the looks of things they are winning over plenty of omnivores). I also don’t want to downplay the care and work that goes into creating this kind of vegan cuisine, which require a lot of specialty ingredients and advanced cooking skills. The chefs here obviously aren’t just cooking out of standard vegan cookbooks, this is food that is adventurous and that has clearly been carefully developed over time. It’s just a case where my particular tastes don’t seem to align with those of the kitchen. And that’s okay! Smith & Daughters has plenty of superfans who will be more than willing to regale you with it’s virtues. Next time I may just stick with the drinks menu.

Smith & Daughters

175 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy

Ph: 9939 3293

6 thoughts on “Smith & Daughters

  1. I think you’ve duly noted what’s great about Smith & Daughters even if you didn’t love your experience. I feel as if Melbourne is overdue for a cool, fancy and inevitably expensive veg*n restaurant/bar, and this one delivers on the quality food, drinks and service.

    I can confirm that the S&D cocktail menu is INCREDIBLE. I don’t know if you scanned the prices but they’re exactly as high as you’d expect. Possibly higher. I don’t know, I rarely drink alcohol at all so anything more than a $3 lime and soda raises at least one of my eyebrows.

    • Smith & Daughters definitely provide something for the veg*n community that didn’t exist before, I do indeed doff my hat to them and wish them every success.

      I did have a look at the cocktail prices, and they seem pretty standard for fancy boozing, so I’d be more than happy to return for an evening of flush drinking!

  2. I found Smith & Daughters completely underwhelming when I went a few months back for dinner. I wanted to love it. I had heard nothing but great things. But the food tasted bland and heavy and rather stodgy. I thought it was a cool place to have a few drinks, but that’s it. Such a pity but its never even a contender anymore when I think of vegan places to go. Having said that, I admire what they do and think its great so many dig it – but can’t help but wonder why I feel so differently.

    • I really wanted to love it! I think for me it just comes down to the fact that I’m just not that fussed with Spanish cuisine, whether it’s vegetarian or vegan, unless it involves a lot of potato (maybe that was where I went wrong? ALWAYS MORE POTATO). I still, like you, really admire what they are doing – I suppose it goes to show that even when you’re a runaway success it’s impossible to please everybody.

  3. Ooooh lucky I like your style in general or I would become one of those insufferable people who says “No, your opinion is WRONG because you have hurt my PRIDE!” I haven’t tried a burrito, but I’ve had a miss on the black bean soup (I ended up ordering corn chips and had it as a dip instead.) Luckily though, my first experience was divine culinarily (because as you say, the service has been absolutely flawless every time I have gone) so when I’ve tried other things and not loved them I can just shrug and move along. For the record, our standard order when we go is a slice of the potato tortilla (by far my favourite thing and I would totally suggest it if you are, like me, a potato person), some of the croquettes (as a non-fish-loving person previously it is the perfect balance for me) and the chickpea and artichoke salad. It leaves me ridiculously happy every time. 🙂

    • I think not going the potato route was a SERIOUS misstep on my behalf, if I do go back I will definitely be focusing on anything potato-based!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s